Skip to content
How we rankRental car rankings

Best rental car companies at JFK

10 companies at John F. Kennedy International Airport (New York, Queens, New York), ranked on what renters actually pay and how they’re treated. Our pick is National Car Rental. Be careful with Dollar Rent A Car and Payless Car Rental.

Checked October 16, 2026 by Nurullah GökdoğanHow we rank
National Car RentalBest overallHighest score at JFK: 68/100.Fewest surprise chargesBest price honesty score at JFK: 3/5.Fastest pickupBest pick-up and delivery score at JFK: 4/5. Emerald Club members pick any car in the Emerald Aisle and check out at the exit gate..Alamo Rent A CarHighest-rated branch★4.4 from 1,259 Google reviews of the JFK branch.Thrifty Car RentalFewest damage disputesBest claims and refunds score at JFK: 3/5.Budget Rent a CarSimplest rulesBest fine print score at JFK: 4/5.HertzLowest under-25 fee$19 a day, the lowest published under-25 fee at JFK.
  1. 1National Car RentalBest overallFewest surprise chargesFastest pickupEmerald Aisle well stocked · Fast gate checkout and return4.4 · 1,564 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option68 /100
  2. 2Enterprise Rent-A-CarFast check-in and friendly staff · Debit cards refused for non-flying (local) renters4.3 · 3,068 reviewsAt the airport60 /100
  3. 3SixtShort lines compared with neighbours · Frequent upgrades to premium models4.3 · 3,245 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option59 /100
  4. 4Alamo Rent A CarHighest-rated branchSkip the Counter works well · Quick returns4.4 · 1,259 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option56 /100
  5. 5AvisLong waits when the counter is short-staffed · Free upgrades reported3.9 · 7,079 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option54 /100
  6. 6Thrifty Car RentalFewest damage disputesVery few Google reviews; most Thrifty renters probably review the Hertz/Dollar listings · Toll device pushed at a high price2.2 · 6 reviewsAt the airport52 /100
  7. 7Budget Rent a CarSimplest rulesHour-plus waits even with a reservation · Fuel charged despite a full tank at return2.8 · 4,261 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option41 /100
  8. 8HertzLowest under-25 feeLong counter lines with one agent at peak times · Upsells at the counter3.4 · 3,558 reviewsAt the airportSkip-the-counter option39 /100
  9. 9Dollar Rent A CarLowest-rated branchHard-to-find counter and return (via Hertz) · Fuel Purchase Option explained as pay-per-use but billed as fixed2.1 · 460 reviewsAt the airport32 /100
  10. 10Payless Car RentalMost surprise-charge complaintsPayless desk closed; sent to the Avis line · Multi-hour waits3.1 · 315 reviewsAt the airportLegit, with caution27 /100

Rank = company Fair-deal score (70%) blended with this branch’s Google rating (30%, less when a branch has under 100 reviews). Awards go to the company that leads on one check; hover an award to see the number behind it. Google ratings are from Google Maps contributors, checked October 16, 2026.

What renters at JFK say

“The Emerald Aisle was packed with great options to choose from and checkout at the gate and rental return were fast”
Rob Salas on National Car Rental · Google Maps · 2026
“we were able to have a 5-minute check-in at the Enterprise office at JFK International Airport”
Paola Melgarejo on Enterprise Rent-A-Car · Google Maps · 2026
“In and out of the airport within 10 minutes of landing.”
Michael Ethridge on Sixt · Google Maps · 2026
“The Skip the Counter feature saves so much time.”
José Roman Castro on Alamo Rent A Car · Google Maps · 2026
“Waiting for an hour only 2.5 attendants maybe just doesn't make sense.”
Oscar “Kokito” Gonzalez on Avis · Google Maps · 2026
“they offered us a toll box at an outrageously inflated price.”
Peter B on Thrifty Car Rental · Google Maps · 2026

JFK rental car questions

What is the best rental car company at JFK?

On our ranking, National Car Rental (68/100). It combines the company’s record on surprise charges, damage claims and disputes with how the JFK branch is rated on Google (4.4 stars from 1,564 reviews).

Which rental car companies are at JFK?

National Car Rental, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Sixt, Alamo Rent A Car, Avis, Thrifty Car Rental, Budget Rent a Car, Hertz, Dollar Rent A Car, Payless Car Rental operate at the airport.

Which rental company at JFK is best for what?

National Car Rental: best overall (Highest score at JFK: 68/100); fewest surprise charges (Best price honesty score at JFK: 3/5); fastest pickup (Best pick-up and delivery score at JFK: 4/5. Emerald Club members pick any car in the Emerald Aisle and check out at the exit gate.). Alamo Rent A Car: highest-rated branch (★4.4 from 1,259 Google reviews of the JFK branch). Thrifty Car Rental: fewest damage disputes (Best claims and refunds score at JFK: 3/5). Budget Rent a Car: simplest rules (Best fine print score at JFK: 4/5). Hertz: lowest under-25 fee ($19 a day, the lowest published under-25 fee at JFK).

Can you skip the rental counter at JFK?

Yes, with some brands: National Car Rental (Emerald Club members pick any car in the Emerald Aisle and check out at the exit gate.); Sixt (Online check-in lets some renters pick up without speaking to an agent.); Alamo Rent A Car (Alamo Skip the Counter: check in on the app and go straight to the car area.); Avis (Avis Preferred members can skip the counter (brand programme; not verified for this location).); Budget Rent a Car (Budget Fastbreak; one reviewer says a new membership takes 24 hours to activate, so join before you travel.); Hertz (Hertz Gold Plus Rewards members can skip the counter (brand programme; not verified for this location).). Join the free programme before you fly.

Which JFK rental companies get the most complaints?

Dollar Rent A Car (lowest-rated branch, 2.1 stars on Google) and Payless Car Rental (most surprise-charge complaints, 3.1 stars on Google). They are real companies and can be cheaper; go in prepared.

Other airports

HNLHonolulu

11 rental companies ranked

OGGKahului

13 rental companies ranked